Innovation at Rio+20

Brazil, country of samba, carnaval, color and caiparinha. But also the country known for the international sustainable development convention in 1992. This convention actually marked my career.

I was studying in those days and became triggered by the question how the private sector could contribute to international sustainable development. Mr Pronk, former Minister of Development Cooperation, decided after the convention to create an innovative way to work on sustainable development. In 1993 the sustainable development treaties were signed with Costa Rica, Benin and Bhutan. All segments of society should become active, and the main principles were participation, reciprocity and equality. In 1994 and 1995 I led student exchange programs between Costa Rica and the Netherlands. We analyzed and discussed each others models of sustainable development. And we wondered how the private sector could become more engaged and leading change. Twenty years later, a new convention on the same topic, in the same nation. I was told 50.000 people will be here for the negotiation. I will join the corporate convention ‘Compact 4 Rio‘, organized by the Global Compact and the WBCSD, which will attract around 3.000 people.

Rio+20 Corporate Sustainability Forum

First Day – June 15
On Friday June 15 the launching event took place. The chairman clearly called upon the corporate participants to be pragmatic, reach clear agreements and provide new insights on how to reach scale. Ideas for new ways to match sustainable development ambitions with core business objectives are needed. Of course there will be a lot of attention to reaching scale in protecting the natural resources (energy, water, biodiversity). But, already there is one full morning session on the Base of the Pyramid (BoP). The corporates I talk to understand what I mean with ‘BoP’, and show interest in our visions and experiences. I wonder what really comes out of these meetings. I understand that we should not expect real change, but one positive thing I can already observe, is that people get new energy and hope being with like-minded people. They feel they are not the only ones searching for new business models. A feeling that most managers of big companies often may have. And creating a specific platform for corporate players also helps to obtain practical examples of what works and what doesn’t. That may lead to a concrete impact of this big meeting, but we will never be able to measure nor prove it. We can only hope that the carbon footprint and resource investment made to be here, may lead at the end to a better world and more wealth at the Base of the Pyramid. I believe that spreading our ideas and experiences at this strategic level, can have as much impact as a concrete meeting or training in the poor communities in the initiative that we are running in the north of Brazil. As long as we keep on doing both, develop in practice, learn from it, and accelerate change by sharing these experiences at a strategic level.

2nd Day – Saturday June 16
Good and inspiring start of the conference. The first session I attend is about accelerating business engagement in the BoP, organized by Business Call to Action and WBCSD. Kick off was by Jane Nelson of Harvard Univeristy. She emphasized on the importance of;

  1. Linking new business strategies with core business operations and value chain activities. Companies should be more strategic, creative and innovative about values of business creation.
  2. The need for fundamental new models of operating; new business models; social business models inside ofthe companies. Also there is a need for new financing models and new incentive models, within companies and external market incentives from financial sector.
  3. Need for more collective platforms, f.e. companies in the agro food sector that create a platform in order to have impact at a systemic level.

This conceptual introduction was immediately followed by an inspiring presentation of the Brazilian cosmetic company Natura. One of the interesting and inspiring challenges they have put themselves up to is to set up an open innovation platform in Manaus. The vision is to convert the Amazon area into a ‘silicon valley’ for local sourcing and sales of natural ingredients based cosmetics.

From the multinational enterprise examples mentioned it was good to hear SAB Miller mentioning their cooperation with DADTCO as being an exciting and successful initiative. DADTCO is one of the companies BoP Inc. works together with as part of our collaboration with IFDC and ICRA in the 2SCALE project. DADTCO brings the processing factory of cassava into the field so farmers can sell the root to the processing industry for all kind of use.

Stuart Hart also added his insights to the meeting. He explained that the first ten years of working on BoP business development provided 5 important learnings;

  1. Embedding; stripping cost and introduce is a non starter. Mentality at ToP doesnt work in bop. Importance of participatory approach.
  2. Converging; 10 years ago focus on selling, but how generate economic activities in order to lift the bop? There tends to be the risk to loose out of sight the environmental side of bop business development, while the Bop is actually the incubator for tomorrow clean tech solutions.
  3. Enabling: it has to be more than CSR. Most innovations end up crushed by existing structures. How to create new innovation white space in companies.
  4. Scaling; most efforts get stuck in pilots. It is clear that parties involved need to be more imaginative in order to make this work. One interesting way is to add the dimension of trickle up. While starting in the BoP, this can very well move up to the MoP and ToP market. This reverse innovation process helps to scale both on volume as well as profit margins.
  5. Measuring; BoP business interventions. Is about creating mutual value. Not about splitting up share, but creating new share for everybody.

The session provided enough food for thought. But also made clear that at least an incipient but growing number of companies are triggered by the BoP proposition. At least 120 people attended the meeting, and contributed actively to the discussions.

Access to Food and Improved Nutrition at the Base of the Pyramid

5 Business InterventionsFive business interventions to achieve social impact, financial sustainability and scale

Improving food and nutrition security through better availability, accessibility, and utilization of food and food products is another complex challenge. It involves a sector where key activities – such as the production, distribution and consumption of food and the identification of food markets – are largely in the hands of private enterprises. Interventions by the private sector in the food value chain can increase the income of the actors in the chain by involving the Base of the Pyramid (BoP) as consumer, producer or entrepreneur. It can increase the availability of food products, make food products more affordable, or increase the quality of food in the BoP.

In collaboration with the Global Alliance for Improved Nutrition (GAIN) and supported by the Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs, we have identified five different business interventions for BoP ventures in a new publication. These interventions achieve social impact, financial sustainability and, potentially, scale:

  1. Interventions focusing on smallholders to improve quality and volume of production. For example, DADTCO, a social enterprise, develops mobile small-scale cassava processing units in Nigeria allowing first processing close to farms.
  2. Commercial buyers to assure access to a supply of  produce that meets specific volume.
  3. Interventions focusing on BoP intermediaries between (smallholder) producers and consumers. For example, Hariyali Kisaan Bazaar is a rural retailer selling agri-inputs and consumer goods through its chain of centres, which also serve as a common platform for providers of financial services or health services.
  4. Adaptation of existing products, services, processes to serve BoP consumers.
  5. Innovative strategies that seek to create new markets at the BoP, through the introduction of new (specialized) products. For example Danone has ventured with Grameen in Bangladesh to create a business Grameen Danone Food Ltd that produces an ultra low cost fortified yoghurt for small children distributed by entrepreneurial Bangladeshi ladies.

5 Business Interventions

The five business interventions are an entry point for companies and other stakeholders to develop products and services to improve access to food and better nutrition with and for the BoP. They are based on extensive study and analysis of existing projects and venture worldwide.

Deliberately choosing one of these strategies, implementing a suitable governance structure and leveraging existing elements in specific models not only enables companies to become more effective in the food value chain, but also to interact and partner with the BoP.

By broadening our understanding of the options available for private sector engagement in providing better access to food and improved nutrition, this report provides key challenges and lessons to scale BoP ventures to be used by the private sector and its partners, be they NGOs or public authorities. Especially in the 2SCALE (Towards Strategic Clusters in Agribusiness through Learning in Entrepreneurship) programme, the BoP Innovation Center will use these insights to develop market based innovation trajectories.

Building blocks BoP Venture

You can download the report here.